Remembering the Brazilian Empire in the Imperial City
Reflections on selective memory
And yet, at the same time as the Emperor rested in Petrópolis under the shade of his lush garden, in Minas Gerais and São Paulo, enslaved men toiled under the sun in sprawling coffee plantations. In the capital, Pedro the Magnanimous’ government contrived exclusive ways to define voters and wrote broadly powerless anti-slavery laws, meant to enact change on very little besides the disfavorable temper of the British government — this being the origin of a current expression referring to token gestures, lei para inglês ver. Only in 1888, after decades of pressure by abolitionists, was slavery finally abolished, when Princess Isabel signed the Lei Áurea. Thus, in an ironic twist of fate, one of the most celebrated figures in the history of the abolition of slavery in Brazil was the royal heiress of a slave state. The very famous golden pen with which she signed the law is in the Imperial Museum. You can buy a replica at the gift shop.
I cannot help but wonder how these people imagine the monarchy, and the time when Brazil had its own Emperor. Maybe they reckon that the word empire sounds nice and would have given them chauvinistic pride, regardless of what awful things it rightfully suggests to others. Maybe they are impressed by Westminster glamor, or by the nostalgic, old world elegance of the Imperial Museum. I’m sure that they bought monarchist flags at the gift shop to go with their golden pens.
Time is ever kinder to the privileged than it is to those who labored under their boots. The Emperor’s palace is sturdy, but the enslaved’s shack is brittle. Though the casa grande stands, the senzala has long collapsed. After a century, it is easy to see the first and forget the second.
One of the most memorable sights in the Imperial Museum to me lies outside the confines of the palace proper. Left from the main gate, close to the backdoor to the gift shop and with no ticket required, there’s a pavillion housing a well known painting — Pedro Américo’s A Batalha de Campo Grande.
It depicts what is considered to be one of the final military engagements of the brutal War of the Triple Alliance, or the Paraguay War. The Paraguayan despot Solano López had managed to evade capture by Brazilian and allied forces when they marched into Asunción, and orders were given to the Imperial army, at that point under the command of the Count of Eu, to chase and capture him.Américo shows a pale French nobleman in military uniform, sat astride a fierce white stallion, leading a charge. The darker skinned enemy soldiers are not attired with the same dignity; for the most part, they wear only rags, possibly a less than respectful depiction of the indigenous Guaraní people that are so prominent in Paraguay. In that country, this event is known as the Battle of Acosta Ñu, and its anniversary is marked by Paraguayan Children’s Day. I imagine that the reader is not blind to what this implies.I’m sure I was never told how Paraguay commemorates the anniversary of that battle in school. I have vague memories of how one teacher told me of the Paraguay War, this awful conflict where Brazilian troops laid waste to another nation, which was so devastated that it may have lost most of its adult men.He said that Britain was to blame.